Members-only podcast episode
Approaches to the Question of Early Christian Esotericism
This is a special podcast episode for SHWEP members only
Already a member? Log in here to view this episode
This special episode is a bit of a freeform excursus on early Christianity and the question of early Christian esotericism. While we are reasonably happy with our summary of some of the issues to do with the interpretation of our evidence for second-century Christianities presented in the foregoing episode, there are some itches that need to be scratched. In this episode, for the hardcore, we explore a bit deeper beneath the rather too-easy dichotomy between early esoteric Christians (like those pesky Gnostics) and their allegedly anti-esotericist counterparts (the ‘proto-orthodox’), which we often find in scholarship. It turns out that, for your host, all Christianity has elements of the esoteric in it, even if they are sometimes hidden under denials, repressions, or ignorance.
Christianity really is a mystery cult, and heresy really is perpetually hiding in the bosom of the Church, waiting to erupt! Irenæus was right about so many things ….
Works Cited in this Episode:
Primary:
Clement of Alexandria on Valentinus’ apostolic wisdom-tradition: Strom. VII 17.106.4.
Hippolytus on Basilides’ apostolic wisdom-tradition: Ref. VII.201.
Irenæus on the beast 666 and all those other sixes: Adv. Hær. 5.30.1.
Secondary:
For Danièlou 1962, Stroumsa 1996, and Williams 1999, see below.
Bernard McGinn. The Foundations of Mysticism. Crossroads, New York, NY, 1991.
Recommended Reading:
Jean Daniélou. Les traditions secrètes des Apôtres. Eranos Jahrbuch, 31:199–215, 1962.
Guy Stroumsa. Hidden Wisdom: Esoteric Traditions and the Roots of Christian Mysticism. Brill, Leiden, 1996
Michael Williams. Secrecy, Revelation, and Late Antique Demiurgical Myths. In E. R. Wolfson, editor, Rending the Veil: Concealment and Secrecy in the History of Religions, pages 31–58. Seven Bridges, Chappaqua, NY, 1999.
Gregory Esteven
October 2, 2023
Having grown up in the Catholic Church, I recall that at every Eucharist, the priest chanted, “Let us proclaim the mystery of faith.”
Earl Fontainelle
October 2, 2023
Yes! The rhetoric is still there, but apparently in the old days, you had to work hard before you got to witness the mystery of faith. Now they proclaim it …. that doesn’t seem very esoteric, proclaiming the mystery ….
Donald Korycansky
October 26, 2024
Not to mention (here at least, although it is discussed at length elsewhere in the podcast) the entirely difficult and mysterious business of the Trinity, which created such problems for the early Church.